This is a thick vanilla milkshake featuring all the peanut buttery goodness of classic peanut butter cookies. You’re going to love it!
Peanut Butter Cookie Milkshake
Oh. My. Goodness. This milkshake is AWESOME!! I’m pretty sure it’s the best one I’ve ever had. I don’t know how else to describe it.
Oh, I suppose I could launch into an elaborately detailed discussion about the heavenly texture of the peanut butter cookie, the oh-so-beautiful flavor of the vanilla ice cream, and the wonderful marriage of the two together in this desert, but in the end – it’s just plain yummy.
If you love ice cream, and you love peanut butter cookies, this milkshake just might become your new favorite thing too!
Cookie Milkshake Recipe
To make the cookie milkshake, you’ll combine a couple of scoops of ice cream in the blender along with a few peanut butter cookies and a splash of milk.
Blend just until smooth and then pour into a glass. Top with a few cookie crumbles and enjoy every sip!
Just one more little bit on my favorite milkshake ever. Choose your favorite peanut butter cookie for this recipe. (I’ve linked mine here.) And grab a carton of your favorite ice cream.
I’ve made these milkshakes with several different kinds of ice cream, one very memorable time I made them with Raspberry White Chocolate Ice Cream it reminded me of these Peanut Butter and Jelly Ice Cream Sandwiches.
Want another fun variation? Check out these Chocolate Chip Cookie Milkshakes by Rachel Cooks.
For classic true peanut butter flavor though, you can’t beat the recipe as written below. Vanilla Ice Cream + Peanut Butter Cookies = Awesomeness.
Peanut Butter Cookie Milkshake
Ingredients
- 1 cup vanilla ice cream about 2 scoops
- 3 medium-size peanut butter cookies
- ¼ to 1/3 cup milk adjust for thickness
Instructions
- Place all ingredients in a blender and blend just until smooth.
- Pour into a glass and top with more cookie crumbles and a cute straw. Enjoy.
Nutrition
{originally published 7/16/14 – recipe notes and photos updated 5/24/22}
Matt Robinson says
LOVE this milkshake and love your goals. It’s not easy to keep up with a blog is it? But you are doing an amazing job!
Mallory says
Thanks, Matt. I’m enjoying every step of it.
Serene @ House of Yumm says
What a wonderful milkshake Mallory!! And awesome job on listing your goals. If you figure out a blogging organization, please let me know! Memorizing 10 verses 🙂 Love this!! Good luck!
Mallory says
Thanks, Serene. Only if you promise to share your organization secrets if you get it figured out first.
Taylor @ Food Faith Fitness says
Love your goals and that you posted them!
I also love this milkshake, so there is a lot of love for this here post! Yay for peanut butter cookies! Pinning 🙂
Mallory says
Thanks, Taylor. Hopefully you guys can help keep me on track.
Melanie | Melanie Makes says
What’s NOT to love about this milkshake?!
Mallory says
I know. It’s pretty amazing, if I can say so. 🙂
Bobbi says
This might just become my fav milkshake too. I love anything peanut butter, so of course I love PB cookies. Mix them with ice cream…ROCK ON!!
Pinning it!
Thanks for sharing!
Mallory says
Thanks, Bobbi!
TidyMom says
lots to love in this post!! and I see this milkshake in my “no so distant” future 😉
Mallory says
It’s so easy there’s no reason not to! Thanks for stopping by!
Robin @ Simply Southern Baking says
I just LOVE peanut butter milkshakes. I think I could have this for breakfast!
Mallory says
Thanks so much, Robin!
Allie | Baking a Moment says
This milkshake sounds amazing and I can’t wait to give it a try! Best of luck to you with your goals. I’m totally with you on a lot of them- I wish I could get on top of some of those things too!
Mallory says
Thanks, Allie. I hoping some accountability helps.
Marly says
Looks like a perfect summer milkshake!
Mallory says
Thank you, Marly!
Jessica @ A Kitchen Addiction says
This looks amazing! I wish I was sipping one right now!
Mallory says
Thanks, Jessica.
Emily @ Love, Pasta and a Tool Belt says
Oh wow, this sure does sound delicious! Thank you so much for linking up with us at The Wednesday Round Up! We hope to see you back next week 🙂
Mallory says
Thanks for hosting!
dina says
it looks yummy!
Mallory says
Thanks, Dina!
Shashi @ runninsrilankan says
So glad I stumbled by – have you ever had Speculous Spread for Trader Joes? The reason I ask is your milkshake looks like a divine drinkable version of it! I am working on remembering bible verses too! Here’s hoping you achieve all your goals
Mallory says
Yes, Cookie Butter is one or my favorites! Thanks for stopping by!
Lydia @ The Thrifty Frugal Mom says
This looks amazingly delicious! Now you have me wanting to add “make peanut butter cookies” to my to do list tomorrow and it is already long enough! 🙂